Organ Mountains Desert Peaks National Monument Sherman Hogue BLM Photo 090716 2

Santa Fe New Mexican: “Permitting Reform” Shouldn’t Be Rushed

This opinion piece was written by and is credited to the Santa Fe New Mexican editorial board, and was originally published in the Nov. 12, 2026, issue of the paper.

So-called permitting reform now being heard in the U.S. Senate is hardly an urgent matter. Come January, a Democratic-controlled Congress will be sworn in, chock full of members with the intellectual heft and policy chops to write a better version of this necessary legislation.

The point of winning, after all, is to pass laws that better serve your voters and constituents. There’s no need to rush through a massive bill — almost 450 pages at this stage — that critics believe would serve as a boon to data centers and energy companies, while ignoring critical environmental and tribal constituencies.

On Nov. 9th the Senate voted 73 to 25 to advance the legislation to the Senate floor, bypassing regular committee reviews. Sen. Ben Ray Luján, thankfully, opposed the bill, saying he could not advance it in its current form. U.S. Reps. Teresa Leger Fernández and Melanie Stansbury also have announced opposition. U.S. Rep. Gabe Vasquez has not stated a position yet, but we hope he stands with his House delegation and with New Mexico constituents who understand the flaws in the legislation.

Note the urgency of stopping it: New Mexico’s tribes are entering a season of ceremonial obligations, busy with preparations for dances and feasts — yet Pueblo leaders traveled this week to Washington, D.C., to speak loudly against this legislation.

That’s how bad the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) is, despite U.S. Sen. Martin Heinrich — a New Mexico Democrat — being a leading sponsor. He should know better.

Pueblo governments are hardly alone in their opposition. Tribal nations across the United States are rallying against the bill, calling it an attack on tribal lands, sovereignty, and cultural sites. They are joined by civil rights organizations, environmental groups, public lands supporters, and historic preservationists who rightly see the legislation as undercutting necessary federal protections.

While red tape in permitting energy projects must be addressed, the bill as written goes too far. It rolls back key provisions in the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act, and the National Environmental Policy Act, and undermines tribal sovereignty consultation rights under Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act.

Critics point out speeding permits through won’t just benefit renewable energy — a chief reason Heinrich gives for backing it. The legislation also could fast-track permits for coal mining, oil drilling, interstate gas pipelines, and gas-powered plants built to fuel artificial intelligence data centers.

The drawbacks already identified must be examined against the bill’s alleged benefits, whether claims to lower energy costs or improve infrastructure. One concern already identified comes under the heading of granting of “project certainty.” This seems to make it almost impossible to withdraw a permit once granted — even if new environmental, health, or public harms are identified as construction is ongoing.

The legislation also will curtail the ability of citizens to stop bad projects through the courts, with statutory limits on lawsuits and establishing narrow legal standing to sue. Courts couldn’t halt construction even when a NEPA violation has been identified.

In New Mexico, where new mining ventures are being proposed at the sacred site of Mount Taylor, as well as the Pecos Wilderness and Chama Valley, an ability to seek relief through the courts is critical.

A law this massive should not be rushed through in a lame-duck session, especially one after an election in which the current ruling majority was repudiated. Stop this bill — if not in the Senate, then the House.

Winners write history. Winners also deserve the opportunity to write the legislation that will impact our air, water and lands for decades, perhaps generations.

This opinion piece by the Santa Fe New Mexican editorial board originally appeared in the Nov. 12, 2026, issue of the paper. I do not own the copyright to this material and make no claim to it. I’m sharing it, with a source link included, because of its particular interest to this website’s audience at this time. Organ Mountains-Desert Peaks National Monument photo courtesy of Sherman Hogue / U.S. Bureau of Land Management.